My Failure as a Watch Reseller

Flipping watches was my gateway into the hobby on a deeper level — and honestly, it’s the origin story for both my watch collecting journey and this blog. If I hadn’t failed as a watch reseller, I never would have considered starting this. The idea crept up on me gradually as I scrolled through Instagram watching influencers show off the money they were making flipping watches. I thought I could easily do the same in my spare time. My ultimate goal was to buy a Rolex with the profits. A lofty ambition for someone with zero experience buying or selling watches.

I spent about a year flipping watches, primarily online across eBay, Facebook Marketplace, and Grailzee. Over that time I invested a total of $17,700 across 11 watches — ranging from $800 to $2,500 each — for a net profit of $1,302. I focused mainly on Tag Heuer and Tudor: specifically the Tag Heuer Aquaracer and Carrera, and the Tudor Black Bay 58. I also sold an Omega Aqua Terra and a few Tissot PRX Powermatic 80s along the way.

On paper, I made a profit. In reality, the majority of that profit came from just two or three watches. The rest I either broke even on, barely cleared anything, or took a loss. But each watch taught me something new.

Lessons Learned

I went into this without a mentor. I watched YouTube videos to prepare, and they helped — but when I made mistakes, I had to roll with the punches and file the lesson away for next time.

Here’s what I learned.

1. Buying Matters More Than Selling

Once you have a watch to sell, selling it is actually pretty straightforward. Good photos and a reasonable price will get eyes on your listing. The hard part — by far — is buying at the right price.

Most listings come from established dealers or jewelry stores who know exactly what they have and aren’t going to sell at a loss. They can afford to sit on inventory. The real opportunities come from regular people looking to offload a watch, but finding quality pieces at a price that leaves room for profit is genuinely tough. Maybe my negotiation skills just aren’t very good and that’s why I couldn’t get people to sell at a lower price. I tried reading up on it, but I’m not sure how much it moved the needle.

2. Factor in Every Fee Before You Buy

This one I learned gradually and it stung a few times. I’d sell a watch expecting a 15% return, and then eBay seller fees and shipping costs would cut that profit nearly in half. It took selling a few watches to really understand what the true costs were at different price points.

The lesson: calculate your fees, shipping, and taxes before you buy — not after. These costs need to be baked into your purchase price, not treated as a surprise at the end. If you can do in-person deals, even better — you cut out fees and shipping entirely. At the price points I was working with, $50 was often the difference between a profit and a loss. Every dollar counted.

3. Know the watches before you buy

   
   

This is especially important for vintage pieces, but it applies across the board. You want to verify that all the correct parts are included and that everything is authentic and correct for that specific reference.

A couple of examples: I looked at a Tudor Prince Date — a discontinued model — where the listing advertised the box included, but the box shown was a modern Tudor box, not the correct one for that reference. In another case, a watch that should only have ever come on a bracelet was listed on a leather strap. Sometimes sellers disclose it’s an aftermarket strap, which is fine. But when they don’t mention it, that’s a red flag. These small details matter a lot when you’re trying to flip — they affect authenticity and value.

Some platforms offer authentication services, which are always worth using. If you’re doing a deal in person, you can bring the watch to your local authorized dealer and ask them to take a look.

4. Beware of scammers

This one is obvious, but there’s a reason for that. On one occasion, a seller asked me to send payment to a third party — a classic scam. When I called him out on it, he immediately went silent. I’ve also heard stories of buyers purchasing a watch, wearing it for months, and then filing an eBay damage claim to return it. My advice: buy and sell the person, not just the watch. If you can verify that someone is genuine, you’re in much better shape. For online transactions, get them on the phone or a FaceTime call. A real conversation tells you a lot.

Final Thoughts

Flipping watches is hard work — not physically, but it demands far more time, effort, and financial risk than I ever anticipated. I have a lot of respect for people like Vookum who’ve built a living doing this, because there is a lot to manage, and if you’re not careful, you can get burned quickly. Knowledge is power in this business.

I eventually stopped because I felt I didn’t have the bankroll to really make it work at scale. On average I was risking $1-2k to make $50–$100. The risk-to-reward ratio just didn’t make sense to keep going.

That said, I don’t regret it. I learned an enormous amount about watches — got hands-on with references I never would have bought for myself, discovered what I loved and what wasn’t for me — and that experience directly shaped my taste as a collector. In a roundabout way, failing as a reseller is what made me a better enthusiast.

If you enjoyed reading, please subscribe to my email list and follow me on Instagram @runningongreektime